(800) 669-5556

Blog

CUB Q&A: Peoples Gas settlement

This month, Peoples Gas and North Shore Gas customers are receiving the first installment of what will amount to about $125 million in bill credits through 2028. 

How much will my bill credits be? 

Peoples Gas customers will get about $140 in total bill credits. For most customers, the credits will appear on one bill per year over the next three years: about $56 in 2026 and $42 each in 2027 and 2028. If your one-time credit is larger than your bill for that month, the credit will carry over to the next month.  

North Shore gas customers will get credits that average out to roughly a few dollars per year over the next three years. 

These credits stem from two settlements resolving allegations by the Illinois Attorney General’s Office that Peoples Gas and North Shore Gas overcharged customers in recent years. The credits for North Shore Gas customers are smaller because their overcharges were not as high. More details below. 

What are the credits about? 

The credits are related to two settlements involving the utilities, the Illinois Attorney General’s Office, the staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission (ICC) and CUB. The settlements were approved by the ICC in May.

  • $75 million in bill credits are connected to a settlement involving Peoples Gas, the Attorney General’s office, the ICC, and CUB. The Attorney General’s Office argued that from 2017 through 2023, the utility inappropriately charged customers for certain things–including ”ineligible capital work, expired permits and unsubstantiated change orders”–through a special “QIP” surcharge on bills.

CUB and other advocates have long contested that the legislatively approved “Qualified Infrastructure Plant (QIP)” surcharge–to help pay for the company’s mismanaged pipe-replacement program–caused hardship for customers by unnecessarily allowing the utility to rapidly increase bills more quickly than going through an 11-month rate case. Legislators originally were told the charge would only cost Chicagoans about $1.14 a month, but from 2017 to 2023, it got as high as $30 a month, according to the Attorney General’s Office. Thanks to advocacy by CUB and others, the legislature let the charge expire at the end of 2023. (North Shore Gas customers were never charged the QIP.)

  • Another $50 million bill credits are connected to a settlement between Peoples Gas and sister company North Shore Gas, the Attorney General’s office and the ICC. It returns to  customers charges associated with the Uncollectible Expense Adjustment from 2019 through 2023. The UEA Adjustment is a charge meant to cover the cost of long-term bad debt – accounts that have not paid their bills for an extended time. The Attorney General’s office alleged that Peoples and North Shore failed to keep arrearages at manageable levels. (The growing number of customers who simply can’t afford their gas bills has been an ongoing problem. About one in five Peoples Gas customers are chronically behind on their bills.) 

Where will I see this on my bill? 

The credits will show up as line items: “UEA Settlement Adjustment” and “QIP Settlement Adjustment.” 

There is also a bill message. Here’s how it looked on one customer’s bill: 

How were the credit amounts determined? 

The amounts were calculated from money that was in dispute in a case before the ICC and then allocated to residential customers. The amounts are the same for everyone, regardless of how much you use or which rate class you belong to. 

I no longer have service with Peoples Gas, but the gas utility did serve me between 2017 and 2023. Can I get a refund?

No. The Public Utilities Act authorizes the ICC to set rates for service, not to order payments to former customers. The exception would be if they were billed incorrectly. Rate changes are forward-looking. (This constraint is why CUB fought for the provision in CEJA that accelerated the refund of excess deferred income tax dollars after a 2017 federal law lowered the corporate tax rate that applies to utilities. ComEd wanted to hold that refund back for almost 30 years. By that time, most of their customers would have turned over.) 

Are there other key details about the settlements? 

Yes. Peoples Gas has also agreed not to charge customers for $130 million in capital investments. This matters because under regulatory law, utilities are allowed to charge customers for capital costs PLUS a profit, or return, on those investments. Customers pay for these investments through their gas bills over several decades, so the total cost to customers is much larger than the original investment. The Attorney General’s Office estimates that removing these costs from rates will save customers $350 million over time.  

Also under the settlement, Peoples Gas will implement accountability and transparency measures in its mismanaged pipe-retirement project that has plunged so many customers into a heating-affordability crisis. Launched in 2011, the project has been behind-schedule and over-budget almost from the beginning, with projected costs rising from about $2 billion to as much as $11 billion. The ICC eventually paused the program, and, after an investigation, ordered Peoples Gas to efficiently and cost-effectively complete the work by 2035.

Under the settlement, Peoples Gas is required to to scope and competitively bid contracts in excess of $25,000 and document and approve cost changes that exceed $5,000. 

Does the settlement have anything to do with Peoples Gas’ proposal for a $144 million rate hike? 

The settlements were part of separate cases before the ICC. But both the rate-hike request and these settlements point to ongoing problems with how Peoples Gas conducts business. 

Under the regulatory system, Peoples Gas is entitled to a return on their investments–and that incentivizes the utility to spend recklessly to increase their profits. Indeed, the company has nearly doubled its rates over the last 15 years, increasing bills by $499 million. That includes the largest gas rate hike in Illinois history–$306 million–just a few years ago. Now, the utility is pushing for an additional $144 million increase that would cost customers $6-$8 a month more.   

This aggressive business model has worked out well for the corporation, fueling record Peoples Gas profits in seven out of the last 9 years and helping WEC Energy Group, their out-of-state parent company, rake in $1.6 billion in profits in 2025. Meanwhile, Chicago families suffer. In September alone, 158,000 Peoples Gas customers were more than 30 days behind on their bills by a total of about $85 million.